First Choice

New castle, PA #8229 Small ($50M–$500M) Healthy CEO: Michael R Vatter

Assets

$94.5M

▲ 0.6%

Members

9,536

—

Loans

$53.8M

▼ 0.4%

Net Worth

12.57%

▲ 0.33

ROA

1.66%

▼ 0.06

Delinquency

0.79%

▼ 0.44

Merger History · NCUA Records

Continuing institution in 1 reported approval pair

· FAMILY 1ST NEW CASTLE, PA · First reported 2025-09 · EXPANDED SERVICES · Reported assets: $16.4M

Pending Filings

Receiving Family 1st 2025-11-22 · Docket NCUA-2025-0675

Merging into Illinois State 2021-09-27 · Docket NCUA-2021-0113

MAIR approvals do not establish whether or when a merger closed. View all NCUA merger filings →

Tools & Analysis // First Choice

Scorecard Performance Report Research Report 🔒 Time-Series 🔒 Forecasting 🔒 Peer Group 🔒 Stress Test 🔒 HMDA Mortgage 🔒 Branch Explorer 🔒

Financial Performance

Loan-to-Share

██.█%

Efficiency Ratio

██.█%

Net Interest Margin

█.██%

Institutional Analysis // Strengths // Risks // Opportunities

Quarterly History // Deposit Mix // Income Statement

Unlock Full Profile

Complete financials, HMDA data, peer benchmarking, M&A and regulatory tracking, Institutional Analysis, and original reporting from The Credit Union Wire — for First Choice and every federally insured U.S. credit union.

Start Free Trial

No charge for 3 days